Trademark Blog

Detroit Trademark Attorney: What Is the Doctrine of Foreign Equivalents?

detroit trademark attorneys

The Trademark Doctrine of Foreign Equivalents: You Say Tomato

It is a given that registration of two confusingly similar trademarks will not be granted by the US Patent & Trademark Office (USPTO). 

As a general rule, this remains true even if one of the two marks is the same word in a foreign language. 

Thus, a trademark for "balik," the Turkish word for "fish," would not be granted if registration of the English word "fish" had already been granted. 

The presumption is that, for consumers who happen to speak both Turkish and English, the likelihood of confusion as to the source of the product or service being sold remains. 

This is the so-called "Doctrine of Foreign Equivalents." It is a basis for the refusal of an application for trademark registration by the USPTO. 

When Does the Doctrine of Foreign Equivalents Apply? 

The Doctrine is more of a guideline than a hard-and-fast rule. 

It applies only when an ordinary American consumer would "stop and translate" a mark's foreign wording into its English counterpart.

However, it has been applied where both marks are in the same foreign language as well, or in two separate foreign languages. 

So when would someone "stop and translate" a mark? 

Courts have held that, when the words are directly literal with no other "relevant connotations," the Doctrine applies. 

Where the words are less than exactly and literally direct, the Doctrine has not been applied. 

The Doctrine applies to Common Modern languages only. 

It does not apply to "dead" languages. However, whether a language is "dead" or not can be a subject of dispute. 

Relevant to this question is the number of speakers of the language in question in the United States, as determined by US Census results. 

Thus, the question may be asked: what percentage of the US population speaks Turkish, or Khmer, or other? 

However, it is safe to say that a language such as Aramaic is truly "dead" and its terminology not likely available as a basis for a USPTO application refusal. 

The use and understanding of a language within a particular market may also be a point of examination here. 

Even if a proposed mark does fall into the shadow of the Doctrine of Foreign Equivalents, all of the usual likelihood of confusion considerations will still be relevant. 

Detroit Michigan Trademark Lawyer: The Bottom Line Regarding the Doctrine of Foreign Equivalents

The bottom line with regard to the registration of a trademark is that it is crucial to retain a knowledgeable attorney to assist you with your application.

A licensed attorney will provide you a measure of comfort in knowing that details such as these will be properly handled and will not upend your chances of a successful registration. 

The Hilla Law Firm is located in the Detroit area but represents clients nationally for trademark matters and offers free video or telephonic consultations. 

If you are interested in discussing the filing of an initial trademark application or defending an office action already filed, please contact us to discuss your matter or click here to directly schedule your initial trademark consultation into our calendaring system

How Do I Register a Trademark for my Cosmetics Brand?

Registering a Federal trademark for a cosmetics brand or product requires that the name or logo uniquely identify the source of the product to consumers. The Hilla Law Firm will walk you through the registration process start-to-finish with maximum customer service and affordable flat fees. (734) 743-1489.

What Is a Trademark Application Descriptiveness Refusal?

Michigan Trademark Attorneys: A name or logo that merely describes the goods or services it identifies to consumers is not eligible for trademark registration. The Hilla Law Firm, PLLC will assist with your Federal trademark registration at an affordable flat rate. Premium customer services, virtual consultations. (734) 743-1489.

Can I Register My Band Name as a Trademark Even If It Is Offensive?

Detroit Michigan Trademark Attorney - A band or rapper or musician's name can be registered as a trademark even if offensive so long as it meets the other criteria for registration. The Hilla Law Firm specializes in helping bands and musicians protect their brands. Affordable flat fees. (734) 743-1489.

How Do I Register a Trademark for a Board Game?

Trademark Attorneys - To be registered as a Federal trademark, a board game name or logo must uniquely identify the product to consumers. The Hilla Law Firm will assist you in registering your Federal boardgame trademark with friendly service, virtual consultations, and affordable flat fees. (734) 743-1489.

Can I Register a Trademark for a Flag or Other National Symbol?

A national or state flag or other national insignia may not be registered, but other elements including so-called "national symbols" may be unless they falsely suggest a connection with the nation or state. Contact The Hilla Law Firm, PLLC to discuss your trademark registration at (734) 743-1489. Affordable fees!
Page: 123456 - All
"See what past clients are saying about how we helped them!"

The Hilla Law Firm did an excellent job handling the trademark registration for my online business. In my case, the process turned out to be complicated as another business registered for a similar name. The Hilla Law Firm expertly handled the situation and my trademark was approved! Kelly
See More Case Studies